I love seeing sign language becoming more visible. More families are learning, schools are introducing ASL, and organizations are recognizing the importance of accessible communication. That’s something I’ve always encouraged as a Deaf educator. But there’s something that continues to bother me. Why do we celebrate sign language while sometimes pushing away the very Deaf community it comes from?
Sign language is not simply a collection of hand movements or a communication tool. It is a language with its own grammar, history and culture, developed and passed down through Deaf communities over generations. American Sign Language (ASL) exists today because Deaf people continued to use, share and protect it, even during times when society tried to discourage it. You cannot separate that history from the language itself.
When I look back at Deaf history, I can’t help but think about the 1880 Milan Congress, when predominantly hearing educators endorsed oral education over sign language. Deaf voices were largely excluded from those decisions, yet the consequences affected generations of Deaf people. Sign language was discouraged or prohibited in many classrooms, and Deaf teachers lost opportunities to teach. Deaf children were expected to learn through speech and listening, even when those approaches didn’t provide them with full access to language and education. Despite all of this, Deaf communities continued signing, sharing their language and passing it on to future generations.
More than a century later, I sometimes wonder how much has really changed. We have Deaf educators, researchers, psychologists and scholars with PhDs contributing valuable knowledge about language development, Deaf identity, education and language deprivation. We understand far more about the importance of early access to a fully accessible language and the consequences when children are denied that opportunity. Yet we still encounter situations where hearing professionals assume they know what’s best for Deaf people, even when Deaf people themselves are telling them otherwise.
I see this concern extending beyond schools. It happens in workplaces, family programs, community organizations and institutions serving Deaf people. Hearing professionals may hold leadership positions, make decisions about Deaf programs and determine what is appropriate, while Deaf people are expected to accept those decisions. Sometimes Deaf culture is treated as something separate from the organization, as though it has no place there. But how can Deaf culture have no place in a school where Deaf children are learning, a workplace where Deaf employees are contributing, or a program where sign language is being taught? Where sign language exists, the culture and community behind it deserve recognition and respect.
This is where audism comes into the picture. It isn’t always someone openly saying Deaf people are inferior. Sometimes it shows up in the assumption that hearing professionals automatically know better, that spoken-language approaches deserve greater authority, or that Deaf people’s experiences carry less weight than the opinions of those in charge. And when Deaf people speak up, their concerns can be dismissed as resistance to change, negativity or being too focused on Deaf culture. I find that troubling because speaking up about our language and community should not be treated as a problem.
Imagine being a Deaf professional working in an environment where your language is used every day, yet your knowledge of that language and culture is repeatedly overlooked. You watch decisions being made without meaningful Deaf involvement, and when you try to share your perspective, you’re not really heard. Over time, that affects morale, confidence and the willingness to contribute. People begin to withdraw, not necessarily because they don’t care, but because they’ve grown tired of having to justify why their experiences matter. When organizations lose those Deaf voices, they also lose knowledge, relationships and connections to the community they claim to support.
I also think about the impact this has on Deaf children. Growing up, we need opportunities to see Deaf adults living fulfilling lives, working in different professions, raising families, leading organizations and contributing to society. Deaf role models offer something that goes beyond learning signs. They provide cultural knowledge, shared experiences, identity and a sense of belonging. A Deaf child who sees a Deaf teacher, researcher, psychologist or leader can begin to imagine those possibilities for themselves. When Deaf adults are pushed out of schools or treated as less qualified to contribute, what message are we sending to the children watching?
I want to be clear that this isn’t about saying hearing people have no place in Deaf education or community programs. Many hearing educators, interpreters, parents and professionals have made meaningful contributions and genuinely care about Deaf people. We need collaboration. But collaboration means listening, sharing responsibility and recognizing that lived experience and cultural knowledge have value. It should never mean that hearing professionals make all the decisions while Deaf people are expected to quietly follow along.
Another thing I encourage people to consider is where their understanding of Deaf people comes from. Much of the older literature about deafness, particularly before the mid-1990s, was shaped by medical, educational and psychological perspectives that focused heavily on what Deaf people supposedly lacked. That doesn’t mean every older document was wrong or audist, but we should be questioning whose perspectives were represented and whether Deaf people were understood through their language and culture or simply measured against hearing norms. Today, Deaf scholars and researchers are contributing important work that challenges those assumptions, including research into language deprivation. We know that the concern isn’t deafness itself but the consequences of inadequate access to language during crucial developmental years. That should change how we approach Deaf education and how we support families.
I often tell people that learning ASL is about more than memorizing signs. You’re learning a language that belongs to a living community with its own history, values and experiences. I welcome hearing people who want to learn, and I love seeing families and organizations make that effort. But I also want them to recognize the importance of involving Deaf people, not simply as occasional guests or cultural representatives, but as educators, professionals and leaders who help shape the work.
If a school serves Deaf students, Deaf educators and community members should have meaningful opportunities to influence decisions. If an organization employs Deaf people, their perspectives should be valued rather than dismissed because they challenge established practices. And if someone is developing a sign language program, qualified Deaf professionals should be involved from the beginning. These aren’t unreasonable expectations. They’re part of respecting the language and the people who have kept it alive.
We’ve already seen what happens when people in positions of authority decide that Deaf language and culture are less important than their own ideas of what Deaf people need. History should have taught us something. Yet I still see the same attitude appearing in different ways, where Deaf people are expected to adapt, accept decisions and remain grateful for whatever involvement they’re offered.
I want to see sign language continue to grow in our homes, schools, workplaces and communities. But I don’t want that growth to come at the expense of the Deaf people who carry the language and culture forward. We should be building stronger connections with Deaf communities, not pushing them aside while continuing to use their language.
Sign language has survived generations of people trying to discourage, control or replace it. Deaf communities have continued to share, develop and protect their languages despite those pressures. We are not simply part of the history of sign language. We are part of its present and future.
So when someone says Deaf culture has no place in a school, workplace or organization, I have to wonder whether they truly understand the language they’re working with and the people they’re serving.
You cannot take the language, push away the community and expect nothing to be lost. And you cannot claim to honour sign language while dismissing the Deaf people who give it life.
